SLIDER

WELCOME

image
Self care, skin care,
& nurturing Mother Nature.

Read more here

Living life with good intention, loving with soul, searching for pure happiness & joy

Shane Dawson x Jake Paul - Sociopath Stigma



Gang, I have some thoughts and I just needed to get them out. I've aired some of my thoughts thus far with people in real life, via Twitter, but there's just *so* much I want to say, it made sense to get it all out right here where I ramble best. So let's talk about the current Shane Dawson series with Jake Paul.

Before I really start getting into this, I have to note here that I'm a big fan of Shane Dawson - I've watched his content off and on for years now, I'm a subscriber of his, and I just generally enjoy his content whether it's him just vlogging with his friends or his conspiracy videos - I enjoy the majority of the content he produces. I always view him as quite a genuine, down to earth character and I've always admired the fact that he confronts any criticism well and will apologise for anything said or done that hasn't sat right with people. Shane recently started to create little mini-series in which he would talk to other YouTube stars to get down to the nitty gritty in their lives. I first got sucked into it all when he met up with grav3yardgirl and then, of course, the very popular series with Jeffree Star. Shane has a knack for comforting people and seemingly making them at ease enough to share anything and everything with him, often leaving him quite emotional and viewers like myself also feeling like you've hopped on an emotional rollercoaster. This is where some concern started when the first indication that Jake Paul would be involved in one of these mini-series. People just didn't want it.

Shane received a lot of backlash upon mentioning any sort of collab with Jake Paul. Many fans of Shane said they didn't want to be left feeling sorry for Jake as he's not a nice person, they didn't want to see Shane giving Jake another platform to potentially build an audience or views, and many fans were adamant that if the series happened, they would be unsubscribing from his channel. So it's fair to say people were pretty heated about this before it even took off. I personally don't know much about Jake Paul or Logan Paul - the majority of what I knew before this series started is that both brothers create content I'm certainly not interested in; content that seems very self-invested but not in a positive way, it's about flashing the cash and a carefree attitude because "I've got money so the rules don't apply to me", and making monumentally bad decisions and thus, setting really bad examples for their mostly young impressionable audiences - of course though, this is just my opinion of it and at complete face value. I'm talking about both brothers here because they're very rarely talked about as separate entities - especially now, almost everything comes back to Logan Paul and that straight up fucking ridiculous Suicide Forest video.



But let's get on with the point of this post. Shane went ahead with the series despite the initial backlash and honestly? I didn't think I would find myself watching it because of how little interest I have in Jake Paul. However (and this is a big however), I'm completely invested in the series now. Shane's channel has some great edited videos - he is very very clever with the choice of music, the shock factor, the entertainment, the fact that he's a very likeable person - and this series definitely reflects all of that but, not necessarily in the best way. The first thing I noticed about the series that was a little 'off' for me was the fact that Shane heavily focuses on the idea of Jake being a sociopath - right off the bat. The focus on this is one thing, but the fact that video is edited in almost a horror story-style way is very off-putting. From the very first video, I had a problem with the fact that 'sociopath' was thrown around a great deal despite Shane himself not really being able to explain what that means. It's a word that is just thrown out there at the start of the series and it instantly holds so much stigma. It's something that Shane creates fear around and uses as a "dun dun duuun!" aspect in the videos.

It might sound silly to some, but I probably wouldn't have been so instantly riled up about it if Shane had approached it with more care and consideration. Even if he had sat there chatting to the camera/Andrew/his viewers at the start but had pulled up a google "what is a sociopath?" search and read it aloud; even if he had done just that I would have felt more comfortable. But he didn't and naturally, some folk got pissed off about it. So that brings me onto the biggest issue I have: the therapist.

In the second video, The Dark Side of Jake Paul, Shane sits down with a friend and certified therapist, Kati Morton. Kati discusses the symptoms of this Antisocial Personality Disorder and lemme tell you, I was not okay with how it was done. Kati has her own YouTube channel and whilst I think that her creating content that openly discusses mental health, particularly from a professional, educated level is great to see on the platform, how she discussed this particular disorder was not okay. Repeatedly throughout the discussion with Shane, Kati refers to the symptoms of this disorder as being "icky", "gross", and "creepy". Now, I feel like this may have been because she states that sociopaths wouldn't typically care what anyone thinks of them - so therefore by default they probably wouldn't care about her saying that right? Wrong. Discussing any individual in that sort of demeaning way is wrong, especially when your whole career revolves around helping such individuals in a sensitive, non-judgemental, neutral way.

My major gripe with this was the fact that Kati, as a professional, should not have used those words to describe anything to do with an Antisocial Personality or Behaviour Disorder. Whilst on the one hand I could play devil's advocate and say that she was just talking to a friend and therefore it might have just came out at the end of the day, she's still a licensed therapist and should never speak about anyone or any symptoms in that sort of a derogatory way. I feel that what was said shouldn't have even come out of her mouth - even if the camera wasn't recording. It's completely unprofessional to talk about any mental illness that way but considering this was about one that has so much stigma attached to it already makes it all the more irresponsible. At one point, Kati shares the statistic that 1 in 25 people are sociopaths. This statistic is then tossed around in such a way that is scaremongering; as if there's lots of monsters roaming around amongst us in society. It's almost laughable that symptoms of this disorder are discussed in a way that makes it sound like we're living in The Purge in real life.



This, for me, is where the accountability really needs to be stepped up on Shane's channel. Since that video, Shane has included disclaimers at the start of videos stating that he doesn't mean to accuse anyone, label anyone, and no one should be trying to self-diagnose or diagnose others based on what has been talked about in this series. The problem with this is, it's all a little too late. As I mentioned before, I always appreciate that Shane will answer criticism and that he will hold his hands up and apologise for things he's said or done but I'm just not getting that vibe this time around. Of course the disclaimers are needed and he can't rewind time to erase past video mistakes but the disclaimers are somewhat empty for me. The main reason for me feeling like this is the fact one of the first things Shane has said in response to the backlash is "I've used footage of friends in the clips mentioning sociopaths!". It just sounds like a weak version of those comments you hear like, "some of my best friends are gay!" "some of my best friends are black!" when someone has fucked up majorly. In the fifth video, we see Kati Morton state that she usually works with eating disorders in her day-to-day career and thus, Antisocial Personality Disorders such as this are not her strong suit - again, if this had been discussed more at the start of the series, it might have helped.

Having now watched the first five videos in this eight-video series, I can say that the majority of the series has been entertaining and eyeopening. It's almost been a YouTube reality show sort of level of drama. I don't watch any soaps on TV or any reality shows, but I imagine the *drama* on those shows would be similar to the 'tea' this series has tried to deliver. Although I've found it interesting as I now want to know more about Jake Paul as a person as there's so much controversy and - quite frankly - conspiracy around who he is, what he's hiding, his relationships/friendships etc., I still feel that there's been a lot of distasteful editing and things said that shouldn't be excused just for the entertainment value. YouTubers like Shane are incredibly popular (the first video of this series has already had 19 million views and it's only one week old), and therefore they have a great deal of influence. If 19 million people have watched him throw around the term 'sociopath', if 19 million have heard him and a qualified professional verge on making fun of the symptoms of a mental disorder, if 19 million have self-diagnosed or diagnosed others as a result of symptoms being relatable or stigma being easily attached to themselves or others, *that* is a major issue.

I'll still be watching the series to the end and will no doubt continue to watch Shane as he's incredibly charismatic and I fully believe that the series has come from a good place and no malicious intent is present here, especially after watching episode 5 as it's more what I'm used to from Shane. It's more about getting to know the individual the series is about and not creating this over-the-top backstory before that individual even makes it on screen and says hello. However, I'm full of hope that this series and the criticism it is now facing is not only educational for viewers but, also for Shane himself. Mental health and anything negatively affecting it is not something that should be joked about or used as a prop for entertainment to cause horror or discomfort. As I've mentioned, there seems to be less of the scaremongering and "horror" elements as the series go on, but it means as a viewer, you are even subconsciously looking out for traits and actions in Jake Paul that reflect the symptoms of this particular Antisocial Personality Disorder just because they've been discussed so feverishly beforehand. I guarantee the same would have happened if Shane had set up the Jeffree Star series in the same way. My views are changing as the series goes on and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens next.

Follow me on Bloglovin'
Twitter & Instagram xo

© NB • Theme by Maira G.